In Conversation With Bruce W. Cole · Ep. 24 · Jun 26, 2026 · 1 hr 1 min

Build Out Loud: Radical Authenticity and Storytelling with Jake Karls of Mid-Day Squares

Pair a great product with radical, honest storytelling, and ask partners what they need before you pitch.

The big idea

Jake Karls believes product plus storytelling is how brands win in consumer packaged goods today. Features like protein and fibre counts are easy to copy and easy to forget, but a real story creates trust and makes people want you to succeed. Mid-Day Squares documented everything from the day it launched Build Out Loud in 2018, including machine breakdowns and emotional struggles, so that shoppers felt like friends of the brand before they ever saw it on shelf. That authenticity cannot be faked, and it only works if you are honest about the cost too. The same principle applies to retailers: instead of a nonstop pitch, bring data to reduce their risk and a human story they can connect with, and ask what they need from you.

Takeaways for emerging brands

01

Building out loud creates demand before you reach the shelf. When shoppers follow your journey online, they actively look for your product among tens of thousands of others in the aisle.

02

Emotional stories beat feature lists. Protein and fibre numbers are easy to copy, but sharing real moments like a factory breakdown makes people root for you.

03

Superfans matter more than viral views. Jake would rather have 1,000 engaged people who produce about 500 superfans than a million views from people who forget you.

04

Titles should match your strengths. Jake stepped down as CMO after eight months and created the Chief Rainmaker role, which let him focus on relationships, content and partnerships.

05

Early proof is something you can create. Texting friends and family helped one consignment box at Real Bagel sell out in an hour, and that story opened the next doors.

06

Ask retailers what they need. Offering help with flyers, charity events or exclusive flavours builds a partnership instead of a one-way pitch.

07

Your form factor and category can be part of your story. The square shape and fresh refrigerated placement help Mid-Day Squares stand out, even when cooler locations vary by chain.

08

Energy is a business asset. After burnout from 90 to 120 flights a year, Jake now treats therapy, coaching, exercise and rest as part of running the company.

Put it into practice this week

  • Share one honest behind-the-scenes story from your business on social media this week, including a challenge, not only a win.
  • Rewrite your product pitch so it leads with a human story before listing features.
  • Compare your title and daily tasks with your real strengths and move one task to someone better suited.
  • Ask your next retail buyer what flyer, charity or exclusive goal you could help them reach before pitching new products.
  • Pair one piece of sales data with one customer story in your next retailer presentation.
  • Book recovery time in your calendar this week as deliberately as you book sales calls.