Selling, Not Listing: How Fortinos Picks New Brands with Stephanie Skalic
Lead with a clean ingredient deck and a real plan to sell after listing, because buyers are in the business of selling, not listing.
The big idea
Stephanie Skalic manages nearly 400 supplier relationships for 24 Fortinos stores, so every pitch competes for limited attention. Her first filter is simple: the ingredient deck and labelling. If those pass, she looks for partners who understand that a listing is only the start. Her team is in the business of selling, not listing, which means brands need to bring education, seasonal messaging and marketing support after the product reaches the shelf. Because social media now creates trends overnight, retailers must react quickly, and brands that help them move fast win. Her own non linear path from bank teller to senior merchandiser also reminds founders that passion and persistence count.
Takeaways for emerging brands
Ingredients come first. Stephanie checks the ingredient deck and labelling before she considers anything else, so a clean formula is your ticket in.
A listing is not the finish line. Buyers want partners who invest in education, seasonal messaging and flyer support after launch, not just a listing fee.
Respect the buyer's workload. With 350 to 400 suppliers and about 150 emails a day, a clear, concise pitch is far more likely to get attention.
Show, do not just tell. Memorable pitches included live absorption demos and a fish oil brand showing a competitor's capsule melting a styrofoam cup.
The customer is the tie breaker. Stephanie's loyalty is always with the shopper, so frame your pitch around what your product does for her customers.
Store staff shape decisions. Nature's Treasure gathers feedback from in store nutritionists and managers through visits, calls and surveys, so winning them over matters.
Social media now drives trends. Retailers must react fast, so brands that can supply and support a trending product quickly have an edge.
Know where the category is going. Functional beverages, sports nutrition, longevity, fibre, fermentation, freeze drying and support for people on medications like GLP-1s are on her radar.
Put it into practice this week
- Review your ingredient deck and label as a buyer would and fix anything unclear before your next pitch.
- Write a one page post listing support plan covering staff education, seasonal promotions and flyer ideas.
- Cut your buyer pitch email down to the five facts a busy merchandiser needs most.
- Design a simple live demo that shows how your product works in under a minute.
- Ask two store nutritionists or managers what questions shoppers ask about your category.
- Track one trending topic on social media each week that connects to your product.