Wellness Fatigue and the Trust Gap: What Canadian Shoppers Want with Lynsey Walker
In a skeptical, overwhelmed market, fewer clear claims and one or two trusted certifications build more trust than a crowded label.
The big idea
Canadian shoppers are tired. Lynsey Walker calls it wellness fatigue: so much health information that people start to tune out and simply want someone to make it simple. At the same time, CHFA's research shows trust is slipping, with more Canadians in 2025 than in 2022 doubting natural and organic labels and questioning whether products work. The instinct for a young brand is to add more claims and more certifications, but in a skeptical world that adds noise. The better path is to choose a few specific claims, one or two well-known certifications and an honest story about how the product is made, and to base decisions on Canadian data rather than borrowed US numbers.
Takeaways for emerging brands
Canadian shoppers are not smaller Americans. CHFA works with Leger and NielsenIQ on Canadian research because US data with 10 percent shaved off misses how Canadians actually think and buy.
Trust in natural products is slipping. CHFA's 2025 consumer research found more distrust of natural and organic labelling than in 2022 and more skepticism about effectiveness, so brands have to earn belief, not assume it.
More claims can mean less credibility. Focusing on a few specific claims and one or two well-trusted certifications reads as more honest to a skeptical shopper than a crowded label.
Wellness fatigue is real. When people feel overwhelmed by information they disengage, so brands and retailers that simplify, curate and explain clearly will stand out.
Uncertain times push people toward wellness. Lynsey notes that when the world feels chaotic, people look to wellness to build resiliency across mental, physical, financial and relational health.
Advocacy works when industry shows up. The Save Our Supplements campaign led to a Hill Day with about 30 MPs, and the Regulatory Forum gives brands a direct line to policymakers.
Field sales experience builds empathy. Lynsey's 18 months on the road taught her what independent retailers need, a lesson for any founder who wants to understand their buyers.
CHFA is building room for new brands. Incubator Alley is becoming The Greenhouse, a space designed to help emerging brands grow at the Toronto show.
Put it into practice this week
- Audit your label and remove any claim you cannot clearly support, keeping one or two trusted certifications.
- Rewrite your product description in plain words a tired shopper can understand in ten seconds.
- Look for Canadian consumer data on your category before your next pricing or packaging decision.
- Sign up for CHFA advocacy updates and add your voice to the next consultation that affects your products.
- Nominate a retailer, rep or peer you admire for a CHFA Award when the window opens.
- Check whether your brand qualifies for The Greenhouse at the next CHFA Now Toronto show.